Natarajan v. Dignity Health

PEER REVIEW: Natarajan v. Dignity Health (St. Joseph Medical Center) (California Court of Appeal, Third Appellate District, C085906)

CMA filed an amicus brief in this peer review case regarding the appropriate legal standard for disqualifying peer review hearing officers. The plaintiff is a hospitalist who lost his privileges after a peer review hearing. In his appeal, the plaintiff does not dispute the factual findings and conclusions of the peer review panel but rather, claims that the hearing officer in his peer review proceeding was biased and should have been disqualified. CMA's brief seeks to equip the Court with the appropriate background, frame, and evidentiary foundation to fashion a robust and clear hearing officer impartiality standard. The brief also suggests guiding principles for a hearing officer impartiality standard. This case is currently pending before the Court of Appeal.



CMA Amicus Brief filed: 12/20/18

Status: This case is currently pending before the California Court of Appeal. Oral argument is scheduled for September 2019

Staff: Long Do


Not a CMA member?

Join over 44,000 physicians making a direct impact on health care legislation.